Showing posts with label alternative rock. Show all posts
Showing posts with label alternative rock. Show all posts

Wednesday

"Falling inside the Black" by Skillet from Comatose

"Falling in the black, slipping through the cracks, falling to the depths—can I ever go back?!"

Another of my favorite songs by Skillet that vies with "Whispers in the Dark" for top favorite, "Falling inside the Black" declares the perspective of someone who's wandered away from Christ (or, at least, has gotten a wee bit depressed), and is pleading with God to pull 'em back up.

If you're a Christian, you've have probably had a "Can you hear me?!" time in prayer at some point. This song is a tribute to those moments. If you're in one of those times, you can plea along with the song's narrator, and if you're not, you can thank God that you've been pulled out of it.

I really need to figure out who else to compare lead singer John Cooper's voice to, instead of only using Seether's singer as an example. Newsong might work, but that's a completely different musical style. Anyway, his wife Korey still makes me think of Amy Lee with a head cold for her backup vocals, even though that sounds so much worse than the reality.

The band's occassional classically trained guitarist makes a nice showing in this song, adding a trace of the symphonic to the sound that really reminds me of Three Days Grace and a bit of Within Temptation (musicwise, not vocally). That would be strange if John Cooper's singing reminded me of Sharon Den Adel's soprano…

Particularly in the "rougher" parts of the song "Falling inside the Black" feature some nice melding of different elements. The result is a very full, flushed-out sound that still wows me, especially due to Skillet being a Christian band. (Even proponents of contemporary Christian music admit that it's often of lesser quality.)

But, like most of Skillet's music, this song demonstrates the band's penchant for a "darker" (minor key) tonality. Some people find it depressing, some creepy, and some relaxing. Unless you're new to About That Song…, you've probably noticed that I'm the last type. If you're of a different type, you might want to steer clear of this song.


Lyrics: 5/5
Music: 5/5
Vocal(s): 4/5
Overall: 9/10

Monday

"Whispers in the Dark" by Skillet from Comatose

"Despite the lies that you're makin', your love is mine for the takin'. My love is just waitin' to turn your tears to roses."

This might be my favorite song by Skillet—or at least my favorite song that appears on their 2006 album Comatose. Nice electronic guitar use. The song overall has an electronic tone (including the vocals, like Amy Lee at the beginning of the Evanescence song "Tourniquet"), but that trait is nicely subdued to keep the song's sound from being outright grating.

I love this song's (perhaps unintentional) emphasis on God's sovereignty. It doesn't matter what lies you tell yourself to try to avoid Him—if you're His, He won't let those fly. He "will be the one that's gonna find you" and "guide you" from the dark to draw you to the light. No touchy-feely 'I'm so great that I can make myself follow God' nonsense. (Romans 1, people. 'Kay—'nuff theology.)

I've compared the lead singer John Cooper to Seether before. The interesting voice of his wife, Korey, doesn't appear in this song that I can hear. It's not my favorite vocal style, but I think that should make my liking of the song say all the more.

The video for "Whispers in the Dark" came out at the same time as the video for the song "Rebirthing." It similarly doesn't seem to have any overarching story that it tells, so you can decide if you want to bother looking it up or not. I wasn't impressed. (Except by the band's refusal to doff shirts and have long hair just because it's considered 'cool'. Having fun seems to be more important to these folks than looking like your normal rock band, not that I can really identify what gives me that impression. Something about how they dance, maybe?)

Now, "Whispers in the Dark" does use the minor key tonality, and this is the band that some people call "creepy." (Personally, I like the sound and find it soothing. But different people respond to the minor key in different ways.) If you can't stand the minor key or hard rock, avoid the band.

But if you do like minor key and hard rock, enjoy!


Lyrics: 5/5
Music: 5/5
Vocal(s): 4/5
Overall: 9/10

Friday

"Rebirthing" by Skillet from Comatose

"For the first time now, I come alive somehow!" and realize yes, there are Christian hard rock bands that suit the minor key tonality that I like.

Within seconds of playing this song, I think Have I heard this, before? No… Yes… No… And finally, at the chorus Yes! I do know this song! And lo and behold, I found out that several songs that I've liked are by this band.

What a refreshing feeling. When you can recognize a particular song within seconds, you know that something's unusually good about that music. In Skillet's case, this Christian band actually reminds me of Three Days Grace in sound, with John Cooper's vocals closer to… um… Seether's. The backup female vocals by John's wife, Korey, are probably easiest to compare to Amy Lee with a head cold. (That sounded bad, but they actually do sound pretty good.)

The minor key alternative hard rock of "Rebirthing" has hints of symphonic rock tied into it, with uplifting lyrics—a combination that some dislikers of the minor key tonality have termed "creepy."

The lyrics of "Rebirthing" capture the life-changing decision of accepting Christ as savior with the imagery of "suffocating" in the world and God's "presence filling up [his] lungs with oxygen." The song narrator dies and revives spiritually in the song. "Rebirthing" doesn't exactly say much more than that, but the imagery is strong and consistent throughout the song.

Personally, I'm quite fond of the song. If you don't like minor key or hard rock, you probably won't like this song, but if you like them, enjoy this song!

And a tip if you're curious about the music video… I found it a waste of time. Maybe you'd pull more meaning from it than I did; all I could see was the band playing the song with a few presumably 'cool' clips tossed in.


Lyrics: 4/5
Music: 5/5
Vocal(s): 4/5
Overall: 9/10

"Good Behavior" by Plumb from Chaotic Resolve

"I'm sick of feeling like a traitor—is this the price for good behavior?"

Tiffany Arbuckle Lee, stage name "Plumb," pulls emotions into this song and could almost (but not quite) be mistaken for Amy Lee (who Plumb actually influenced). Plumb's third album was coming out when Evanescence launched its first.

A gentle albeit synthesized beginning switches to a harder metal element. (Plumb's 2006 album Chaotic Resolve melds her original edgy dark rock sound with her more recent pop style works.) This sound is again reminiscent of Evanescence songs like "Taking Over Me."

In fact, Plumb could even be thought of as a Christian edition of Evanescence, since she likewise honestly explores dark topics in her lyrics. "Good Behavior" speaks of how constricting rules can have the reverse affect of what's intended.

The narrator has been surrounded by rules and kept inside them, but it's driving her mad. There's no salvation in following a mere set of rules, she knows, and she's "sick of feeling like a traitor" from playing hypocrite.

That the narrator breaks free—and goes recklessly wild because of it—is a warning to many of us, I think. It can be so easy to narrow things into categories of rules that children in particular can be overlooked as people who need (as they grow) to learn why the rules are there.

Overall, it's a fine enough song (along with "Better") that I'm adding Plumb on my "to-get" list.


Lyrics: 4/5
Music: 4/5
Vocal(s): 4/5
Overall: 8/10

Wednesday

"The Bird and the Worm" by The Used from Lies for the Liars

Okay, I admit—found this song from the Moonlight episode "Arrested Development," when Mick's getting beaten up by the 16 going-on-200 vampire. First Moonlight episode I saw, and I liked it enough to try another episode or two, which got me hooked on the rest.

This single from The Used's third studio album Lies for the Liars is evidently one of their cleaner ones. (Evidently the band doesn't mind using, for example, the f-word.)

The mysic and lyrics of "The Bird and the Worm" have been called a dark-toned edition of Panic! at the Disco. Maybe that's why it caught my ear. I'm personally also reminded of Three Days' Grace. Bret McCracken has similar vocals to those other two bands, too.

Most people aren't sure what the song means. Some suggestions for the meaning of "He crawls like a worm from a bird" have ranged from a regular person struggling with unavoidable events in life to an abused individual fleeing the abuser.

In any event, the end result is a kinda gritty-sounding song that meshes a few different sounds and tempos with the growling and such. I'm not quite sure how to describe it besides "darkly rough." It has something of a post-grunge feel to it, even if the band doesn't classify it that way.

Overall, it was a very good choice for where it was put in the Moonlight episode. Personally, I don't care for listening to it on its own, though others who like the genre will likely be quite fond of it.

And the music video is bewilderingly freaky. (Oh, and a bit gruesome.) As a bit of a warning.


Lyrics: 3/5
Music: 3/5
Vocal(s): 4/5
Overall: 7/10

Monday

"If Everyone Cared" by Nickelback from All the Right Reasons

"If everyone shared and swallowed their pride then we'd see the day when nobody died" sums up this song's message and pinpoints a Christian's hesitation with it. "If Everyone Cared" is the sixth single Nickelback released from its 2005 album All the Right Reasons in the U.S. and the fourth worldwide (with a few exceptions).

In "If Everyone Cared" the Canadian band declares that, if everyone cared enough to band together to help others, they would eliminate world problems, and the music video accents that with the tales it includes of people caring enough to work for betterment, improving others' lives. Apparently funds from the sale of this single go to certain charities like Amnesty International.

My hesitation comes from the assumption that everyone banding together would eliminate world hunger and such. I'd guess that the Nickelback members would claim that man (in the human sense) is basically good. In my worldview of people being innately selfish and sinful and unable to care for others apart from the grace of God, this philosophy doesn't fly so well. Though it could probably be argued that my issue's a matter of thinking the band's humanistic dream impossible.

The song's a standard short pop but softer rock with a nice beginning that doesn't go much of anywhere, musicwise. It sounds… normal. Nothing special, besides the older voice of Chad Kroeger that reminds me of Newsong. (I think of it as "rough"; I'm not sure what the technical term is, musically.)

Despite the short length of "If Everyone Cared", it's extremely repetitive. I grant them kudos for an admirable idea, but I really won't be looking for this song to listen to on my own; not my preferred sound.

The song's currently offered on the band's MySpace page if you want to listen.


Lyrics: 3/5
Music: 3/5
Vocal(s): 4/5
Overall: 7/10

Friday

"My Last Breath" by Evanescence from Fallen

"Can you hear me? Can you feel me in your arms / holding my last breath…"

One thing I really like about Evanescence's 2003 album Fallen are all these fun little stories from the perspective of someone dying in a tragedy. (I know, I know—I'm morbid.) I even used the "fade to black" to entitle a fan fiction I wrote taking place in the Jedi Purges. This song's narrator is being held by her lover (in the traditional sense) who's weeping as she dies.

The music style definitely requires you to like rock or metal, but it's lovely despite the synthesis (unless you can't stand the electronic style instruments). Reverberating synthesis mixes with "clean" orchestral to produce a song that'll stick with you.

Which is why, if you find "dark" songs depressing, I strongly advise you not to listen to this song. If, like me, they don't affect your emotional health and you don't mind things like electronic guitar, I suggest you listen.

Amy Lee sings on her better end here, too, though it could've been a tad louder to stand out a bit more. That probably would've improved it, but it's still a very strong song. I was entranced by it the first time I heard it.


Lyrics: 4/5
Music: 5/5
Vocal(s): 4/5
Overall: 9/10

30-Second Song Preview:

Wednesday

"Work" by Jars of Clay from Good Monsters

"Do you know what I mean when I say, 'I don't want to be alone'?"

Yeah, it's a Christian song talking about how hard life can be and how letting yourself drown can sometimes seem to be. ("Now all the demons look like prophets and I'm living out / Every word they speak".) The song narrator is clutching life—er, well, his friends' good company—by his fingertips. The danger comes when he's alone, and he clings to company to avoid it. Staying alive takes "Work".

The band Jars of Clay produces surprisingly good music, considering they're part of Contemporary Christian Music (CCM). Okay, the acoustic guitar-based rock starts to sound kinda same ol', same ol' after the first album or two. The tempo in and style of "Work" seems a bit of a compromise between the heavier rock of The Eleventh Hour and the soothing tones of other albums.

(Caveat here: I only own all their albums through The Eleventh Hour, including the original Christmas one they did, so most of my exposure comes from the first five CDs. They've had five since. But I think it may say something that this song from CD #9 resembles #1–5.)

Dan Haseltine's voice soothes and melds well with the well-mixed music. Still, the lyrics get a bit overrepetitive with the nearly-continuous "what I mean when I say, 'I don't want to be alone'?"

The music video is also a bit creepy. The band performs the song—eeek, and I thought Nightwish looked weird—while the room's filling up with water. Right at the end, the room's full.

Er… points for symbolism, but not very memorable scenery. At least, not memorable for me. To be fair, I have been reading vampire novels this week (Eclipse and Sunshine) and am writing another (fine, so it's more werewolf than vampire), so maybe my creepiness tolerance has spiked enough that this video isn't making much of an impression.


Lyrics: 3/5
Music: 4/5
Vocal(s): 4/5
Overall: 7/10

Monday

"Disguising Mistakes with Goodbyes" by Emery from This Weak's End

"Have you looked up Emery yet?"

I hesitate. "I've been busy," I finally answer my brother.

"I was just wondering," he insists. "I really think you would like their music."

My brother may not be able to tell when something's a half-beat instead of a full beat or be able to appreciate Green Day (who isn't hard to hate), but he does have a decent ear for noticing when a band resembles another one I like. Sort of. The music of "Disguising Mistakes with Goodbyes" does remind me of some other songs I like.

My first thought upon hearing "Disguising Mistakes with Goodbyes," though, was why so much screaming in the background? That would have been a lot more striking with more pointed screams, used in particular locations. But Emery sadly overkills the technique. Okay, that first one got my attention, I think, but then by the third time I'm annoyed, and then there's a fourth.

But when they're singing—whichever two of the guys actually sing in this song—it's quite attractive. The nice voices remind me Chester Bennington of Linkin Park.

"Disgusing Mistakes with Goodbyes" expresses the emotions of a relationship on the rough seas from a fight and one member trying to get past it. The band warns that "Words can breathe more life or death"—words hurt.

No cussing or harsh language appears in the song, though it does hint that the relationship might be intimate without stating whether the twosome involved are married. One party may also be leaving in the end ("I can't stay here").

The melodic music pleases the ear and offers some creativity, but there could've been more. Even so, the band's more than "decent" when compared to similar groups. Emery is one of those bands whose all-Christian members decided to pursue their career without a "Christian" label, because they're wanting to reach the unsaved. When compared to most Christian groups of comparable style, it's very good.

Nonetheless, a few points in the song felt clumsy. But that doesn't mean I wouldn't be willing to look up more songs from the band's 2004 album This Weak's End.


Lyrics: 4/5
Music: 4/5
Vocal(s): 4/5
Overall: 7/10

Wednesday

"Better" by Plumb from Chaotic Resolve

"I don't wanna hate; I don't wanna be broken; I don't wanna hate you!"

Now, that's a nice twist of lyric, as is "But in the end / what leaves you broken in the end / makes you better!"

I first heard "Better" on Pandora about a year ago before I even considered making this blog, and liked it enough to take "I like it!" I ultimately left Pandora for several months (mostly because they lacked certain bands and songs I wanted to hear). I forgot about the song, then popped back in one night and decided to listen to my "gothic rock" station I'd made there. "Better" came up, and I immediately jotted it down to review it.

Turns out, Plumb's a Christian singer. I almost regret learning that, since it made me realize what the song reminded me of: other CCM (contemporary Christian music). It almost could be Evanescence meets Rebecca St. James. Okay, that was a weird comparison. But the alternative slightly-gothic rock music blends with enough attractiveness and memorability to warrant an "above average" rating, albeit too conventionally for me to hand a "5".

Plumb, whose actual name is Tiffany Arbuckle Lee, sings prettily. Again, I'm reminded of Evanescence's Amy Lee with traces of Rebecca St. James and even Flyleaf's Lacey Mosley (in a good way). Nonetheless, "Plumb" sounds a bit overly breathy when she's trying to sing quietly. It's a bit annoying.

Now for the lyrics. As you can probably guess from the quotes I have above, "Better" discusses not hating someone who abuses you. The song specifically speaks of the unbeliever who persecutes the Christian "because of fear." It's encouragement to the Christian who is facing a hard time, perhaps getting emotionally torn to pieces by someone. "What leaves you broken in the end makes you better." Notice that unusual statement.

For a song in general, it's well above average. For CCM, it's extraordinary.

UPDATE: I've learned that Amy Lee actually credits Plumb as one of her influences for Evanescence. So small wonder they sound comparable.


Lyrics: 5/5
Music: 4/5
Vocal(s): 4/5
Overall: 8/10

Monday

"It's Not Over" by Daughtry from Daughtry

"My life with you means everything, so I won't give up that easily." 'Cause evidently "It's all misunderstood", his actions that caused the woman to leave the narrator. "It's not over", he insists, since she's "the only one" for him and he'll "try to do it right this time around". He's determined that neither of them "get caught up in" themselves.

The promise of change and working to make the one relationship work instead of bouncing to another one offers a welcome shift from some songs. The music video suggests the man served jail time. (The music video isn't really appropriate for children, though it's cleaner than those of many popular bands. It still shows clips of the heads of a couple presumably making love in the modern sense of the phrase.)

Though the song staunchly declares that "It's Not Over", it's because of his willingness to work at making it turn out rather than an immature determination for things to just go back how things were that seems to popularize songs.

"This love is killing me" serves as my complaint about the lyrics. Uh, right.

Chris Daughtry, who was the forth-place finalist on American Idol's highly popular fifth season, sings eloquently. Words and emotions come through his singing, though it really sounds similar to a lot of male rock vocals.

The guitar-based rock (post-grunge) music also offers more layered variety and smooth melding than is common for rock. It flows very well with the song and isn't afraid to shift within the song as necessary. For the genre concerned, the music is top-notch.

Okay, so I tend to prefer female vocals with this kind of music, but that's my preference. Daughtry does offer a pretty good and mature song in "It's Not Over".


Lyrics: 4/5
Music: 5/5
Vocal(s): 4/5
Overall: 8/10

Wednesday

"Lips of an Angel" by Hinder from Extreme Behavior

I used to think I liked this song a little… before I paid attention to the lyrics.

It's the guy's side of a phone conversation with an ex-girlfriend or a woman he wished could be his girlfriend, but she's evidently married or in some other situation that makes them unable to be each others' significant other at this time. Evidently they "never really moved on".

"Does he know you're calling me? Will it start a fight? No, I don't think she has a clue" concisely embodies what I dislike about this song. I'm sure this kind of thing happens, but the implicit deceit and lack of faithfulness makes me dislike it. The man does ask "Honey, why you calling me so late?" but "I gotta whisper 'cause I can't be too loud. My girl's in the next room; sometimes I wish she was you."

There is no swearing or any of that, and they do apparently stay faithful in action if not in heart to their respective partners. But it's that unfaithful at heart that's the issue, here. And evidently, that's mild for Hinder, as their other single title "Get Stoned" suggests.

Austin Winkler's vocals are soothing. Not good, not bad, but soothing. And those are the best part about this song. The music is stock, the only personality to it being the usual band imitation. It's tolerable, but really… Can't radio stations find something better to play?

Hm… Hinder's "Lips of an Angel" or Evanescence's "My Immortal"… Hard choice.

Not.


Lyrics: 2/5
Music: 3/5
Vocal(s): 3/5
Overall: 5/10

Monday

"My Sacrifice" by Creed from Weathered

"I just want to say hello again…"

Before… what? Sounds like you died. You can say "hi" when dead… how?

Creed's oddly popular in Christian circles. I guess it is better quality than Christian rock in general, but… Creed isn't a Christian band. They use Christian allusions, true, but the band isn't Christian.

Maybe it's just the bands I tend to listen to, but it seems like guy singers prefer guitar-based rock, gals piano-based. The guitar-based music is better than some, but it doesn't sound anything special.

Um, have you tried opening your mouth? The singer has an average voice, demonstrating an average slur as he sings his not-so-average tribute to friendship and the sacrifices of 9/11 heroes.

Lyricwise, it's refreshing to hear about the strength of a non-romantic friendship. Unfortunately, it doesn't feel very fluid. Maybe it's me, but that's my impression of it, at any rate.

It's an okay song. I don't mind it; not that I particularly like it, either.


Lyrics: 4/5
Music: 3/5
Vocal(s): 3/5
Overall: 6/10

Thursday

"The Ghost Woman and the Hunter" by Lacuna Coil from Comalies

"Staring in the sun… no rays down on me…"

Yep, another ghost story. One of if not my favorite song by Italian band Lacuna Coil, "The Ghost Woman and the Hunter" is the softest song I've heard by them. …Actually, it's probably comparable to "See Me in Shadow" in style, though the sound is different enough that you probably won't hear that unless you're looking for it.

Okay, the song's still normal Lacuna Coil, bit tricky to follow with an odd lyrical flow. Not that it's bad—it's just one that takes some major thinking to put the lines together in any sense whatsoever. Cristina Scabbia sings prettily if you like her voice, and there's no screaming in this song.

The questionable part of this song is when the ghost says "calling on your sins, you're here in my dreams." Evidently the Ghost Woman's hunter "wants to be" her. But he's passing beyond her so he'll never see the tears she cries. It's interesting, from the ghosts perspective. (I actually find it kinda cute, a lovesick ghost lamenting her living lover. Um… okay, I'm weird.)

The music is the usual lovely, well-mixed resonating mix Lacuna Coil does, with their usual instruments. It's a sound that can grow on you, as I found from experience.


Lyrics: 4/5
Music: 5/5
Vocal(s): 4/5
Overall: 8/10

Monday

"See Me in Shadow" by Delain from Lucidity

"Standing by the paintings of your dreams that you have awoken, and all the purples and the greens have turned to black…"

Okay, yeah, it's a bit of a dark song at the first glance. But it's admitting how we're all imperfect and have dreams that must be released at some point. It's a very sweet song, like Nightwish's "Eva" and Evanescence's "My Immortal".

The language is very clean, and "See Me in Shadow" admits how no one's perfect, all "our lives do have our imperfection". Having "eyes wide open but still blind to see what really matters" is sadly more common than we like to remember.

I'm not sure, though, if "Forget yourself and who you are; another life is not that far" is meant to refer to restarting one's own goals in life or a reference to reincarnation. The music video has the wedding-garbed singer looking over the holdovers from her wrecked wedding before heading into a lake. So literally, the song might be talking about reincarnation, but it might be intentionally symbolic. The listener will have to decide how to accept that.

For anyone who's heard "Frozen", it's similar instrumentation. "See Me in Shadow" mixes rock music with the lovely piano and violin that opens the song and covers the verses, with electric guitar and such appearing for the verses.

Charlotte Wessels has a nice voice that is only slightly hindered by her Dutch accent. It mainly appears in slight sounds that she has an accent, but it's no biggie. Her voice sometimes echoes or changes a note in a verse to suit the song.

If you've liked such songs as "My Immortal"—this is better melded than that one's band version—or "Eva" I suggest you check it out.


Lyrics: 5/5
Music: 5/5
Vocal(s): 4/5
Overall: 9/10

"Hanging by a Moment" by Lifehouse from No Name Face

Not bad guitar, but sing, dude! (I'm hardly one to talk about voice quality, but at least I don't try to sell myself singing.)

The lazish voice demonstrates in the chorus that Jason Wade can sing better than he does for most of the song. Why doesn't he? I get the distinct impression that he's trying to mimic someone else's sound on the not-so-good verses. Bad move.

Musicwise, it is, by and large, better than many songs. It has its faults, but it sounds like it would be a fun one to play or hear just in itself, apart from the singing. The initial guitar slowly adds other things, like the oh-so-standard drum. (I don't mind drums, but they're starting to get a bit predictable now that I'm listening for them.)

The lyrics are a standard love story—well, not-so-standard, I guess, in that it's clean and the guy's talking about the girl as if she's something worthwhile. He's "falling even more in love with" the girl, willing to give up of himself for her sake. But it is average in the shallowness of it.

Eh, it's okay. Call me spoiled, but I'd rather go listen to something else.


Lyrics: 3/5
Music: 4/5
Vocal(s): 2/5
Overall: 6/10

"Dark Wings" by Within Temptation from Mother Earth

"Don't you die on me—you haven't made your peace!" This part of "Dark Wings" more than any other draws me back time and again to listen to this song. It's not Within Temptation's best, but even then it's higher than average.

Anyone who's read Frank Peretti's This Present Darkness or Piercing the Darkness might find themselves reminded of those books with this song, but it's even more Christian-ish than those books in some ways. The narrator is a powerful being that didn't know what she could do until she was chosen to fight. Even with the magic and power that her side has, they're still only able to defeat the "dark wings" through someone's sacrifice, reliquishing their soul.

As a Christian, I of course think of the parallel to Christ. He gave up His everything to be the sacrifice so we could win, in a sense; his death provided a bridge for the chasm of our sin. He is the Light that causes "the night [to turn] into the day".

Sharon Den Adel's voice soars over the music. That is, it was supposed to. It could've been mixed a tad better in trying to accomplish that, as the album version of "Ice Queen" demonstrates, but it's not so bad that it's obvious to a common listener.

But the music! A critical listen to the music proves disappointing, as they've done much better. It's closer to The Silent Force than The Heart of Everything in sound, but then the Mother Earth came out before those two.

If you like the band, you'll likely like the song, but it may not be your favorite.


Lyrics: 5/5
Music: 4/5
Vocal(s): 4/5
Overall: 8/10

Thursday

"Boulevard of Broken Dreams" by Green Day from American Idiot

That I can sing along with this song somewhat when I hear it says something. Not only do I rarely listen to the radio, but my brother wails whenever this band comes on, so the station is changed when he's in the car, which is most of the few times that I hear to the radio. (Bit hard to stop someone who's 100 lbs. bigger than yourself and still growing.)

Green Day sounds… unusual. I know, this freaky gal has little room to talk considering she likes Nightwish. But I can hear why my brother hates Green Day—and why one friend loves their sound (though she admits that she doesn't care about lyrics).

One thing Green Day certainly isn't is stock. As far as whether their music is above or below average really depends on if you like the style or not. It's definitely rock, but it kinda defies explanation. I find the verses soothing while not slow enough to be calming, and the choruses metalish while not hard enough to wreck my pulse. A lot of (electric) guitar, cymbals, and other things I can't identify mesh together in a combo you might hate or like, but at least the melding doesn't sound like the mixer can't hear very well.

The same love/hate response applies to the singer's voice. Billy Joe Armstrong is as much of Green Day's odd sound as the rest of it. The voice is easy to hate or love, once you get used to it.

Now, lyricwise, there's a problem. The f-word appears in this song, and it's obviously buzzed out. You might not realize what's being said in the censored version, but if you listen for it, you can figure it out pretty easily.

Overall, the song talks of walking alone down the "boulevard of broken dreams," which is "a lonely road", but it's "the only one [the singer] has ever known"; "it's home to" him. Sometimes he wishes for someone to find him, but till that happens he's alone on the road. Despite the song's dark loneliness of lyrics, the sound doesn't really come across that way. The song narrator's attitude seems to be saying "This is me" with a shrug, rather than a plea for company that most songs with this topic are.

At least there's the censored version, but that crude word choice really wasn't necessary.


Lyrics: *2/5
Music: 4/5
Vocal(s): 4/5
Overall: *6/10

*Contains the f-word.

Wednesday

"Hand of Sorrow" by Within Temptation from The Heart of Everything

Within Temptation's ministories often blow me away. I've always suspected fantasy leanings in the songs, though I'm hopeless enough with symbolism that I could never be sure that songs like "Angels" and "Forsaken" weren't just metaphorical.

"Hand of Sorrow" brings the fantasy element to fore in a tale reminiscent of the old stories of nobodies with mystical powers. The story is of one such nameless orphan who swore fidelity to the crown as a child, little realizing the ruler's wickedness until too late. Now an adult, he's trapped in serving the crown's wishes even as it builds "a noble land of lies." He's further torn between his honor in the oath and the woman he loves, and he cannot have both.

Sharon Den Adel demonstrates her masterful control of her voice in "Hand of Sorrow", as she does on much of the new album The Heart of Everything. Her Dutch accent appears a bit in the lower register; noticeable, but entirely understandable. She uses the heights of her voice to accent the song, producing a song that's both rock and beautiful.

Numerous layers flow together in the song, the slow beat hastened by a second layer. Each individual element sounds like it could be separated from the song and still be thought attractive. The composite result sounds even prettier than the individual sections, bringing the old times of knights and castles to mind despite the very modern music.

"Hand of Sorrow" is one of my favorite songs that I've heard from The Heart of Everything.


Lyrics: 5/5
Music: 5/5
Vocal(s): 5/5
Overall: 10/10

"End of All Hope" by Nightwish from Century Child

The title "End of All Hope" sounds familiar, so I click on the song in curiosity. "Is this—the end of—all hope?!" I jerk in my seat, pulse skyrocketing from the hectic beat and clipped chorus. You would think that I'd know to be careful with Nightwish by now. (I promise I won't always review so many Nightwish songs.)

The beat in itself is done as a form of music, with more added. It's unapologetically synthetic in its almost techno declaration of apocalypse. The chorus can be followed without much trouble, but much of the verses of the song is hard to follow from the intentional emphasis.

Nightwish as usual manages to produce lyrics able to give the Christian pause. The narrator has lost innocence and faith, a common premise with what I've heard of Nightwish, and not only from Century Child. The narrator of "End of All Hope" might be suggesting that having "This life unforgiven" "is the birth of all hope", a distinctly unappealing premise. "It will end with a birth" doesn't seem to fit in that, though, so I am again confused.

Beyond that, the lyrics of "End of All Hope" are clean, using metaphor instead of the crass language some artists resort to. Tarja Turunen's operatic voice particularly suits the apocalyptic tone of this compelling song from Century Child.


Lyrics: 4/5
Music: 4/5
Vocalist(s): 5/5
Overall: 8/10