Showing posts with label Barlow Girl. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Barlow Girl. Show all posts

Thursday

"5 Minutes of Fame" by BarlowGirl from Barlow Girl

"Was it worth it, what I gave away for five minutes of fame?"

The song's narrator "found that morals can't take you up to the top; your standards pull you down". Still, all she gained was "five minutes of fame", now "over; no one knows [her] name". She "gave up the only thing that mattered for this empty life".

The focus "5 Minutes of Fame" has on the perspective of someone who's lost her integrity for popularity's sake could be called a bit dark. Nonetheless, it is the strongest way to encourage girls fighting the desire to be popular at their beliefs' expense. The song further personifies the immaturity of giving up all that matters for a few empty minutes in the end, where the narrator whines about no one paying attention to her.

I would've preferred more singing from all the sisters rather than the one in this song, but it worked. Better than most, but not anything to say "wowsers" about. The most disappointing thing for me is the music; it's… pretty normal pop rock. Now, for Christian pop rock, it's especially good. Compared to pop rock overall, it's barely on the better end, and I'm not convinced that my liking of BarlowGirl isn't prejudicing me on that evaluation.

Okay, I'm distinctly reminded of Superchick with this song's music. It's a rapid-beat pop-rock that Superchick tends to prefer, but BarlowGirl still marks it with their standard thumbprint, mixing warning of what to avoid while encouraging those who've fallen that they can get out. "This time [they can say] no".

For edifying pop rock geared for young unmarried women, even BarlowGirl's first album has some pretty nice songs. Now, if I could just go and review some from their other CDs, including their new one…


Lyrics: 5/5
Music: 3/5
Vocal(s): 4/5
Overall: 7/10

Monday

"Clothes" by BarlowGirl from Barlow Girl

Ah, so you've noticed how… lacking clothes have gotten? So few things seem to fit—especially if you're well-endowed up there. (If you wouldn't know, just trust me on that one.) Clothes just "don't seem to fit you and me anymore."

The Barlow sisters have noticed that and the mockery they (and other young women) receive for intentionally dressing modestly, and they return the treatment in "Clothes," demonstrating the ludiocrity of the matter, producing an intentionally silly song. "Pay so much for clothes so small—was this shirt made for me or for my doll?"

Sure, everyone says "Modesty is out the door" if you want to "look like a model." BarlowGirl returns, "Don't want to be a model—they don't eat anyway." "Clothes that fit are fine!" they insist. Question why people demand the immodest clothing, and refuse to be a sex object! (In keeping appropriate for younger audiences, they don't say that last one point-blank.)

Did I mention they dress modestly, too? These girls certainly practice what they preach!

The music isn't their best. It's not bad, but it's… a bit overloud pop rock. They've done a lot better on the music aspect. And their voices could have stood out a little more—I suspect that would have made the song sound a lot better, and at one point they sound downright weird. As things stand, if you want to enjoy the fun lyrics, you have to sit through an otherwise not-so-great song.


Lyrics: 5/5
Music: 2/5
Vocal(s): 3/5
Overall: 5/10

Thursday

"She Walked Away" by BarlowGirl from Barlow Girl

"She walked away; she left all she had believed in." Sometimes, a child of believing parents leaves the faith—even for non-religious folks, a child might leave a home without realizing they "love her." BarlowGirl captures the emotions of that in "She Walked Away."

The girl "couldn't take one more day; home was her prison now." "I'm finally on my own; don't try to tell me no," she says, while her parents plead to God, "tell her please come home!"

But the lyrics don't stop there. It's not just a story but a message to such a girl. "She Walked Away" tells the girl who's left, "The choice is your alone now. Tell me how this story… ends…" A quote from the story of the prodigal son follows, where the father runs out to greet and welcome his son home.

The sisters' vocals are in top form on "She Walked Away." They are excellent. The music isn't anything special, but at least it's well done. Hints of above-average elements appear in the music, but it's not enough for me to rate it that. They could have done better, as is the case with many of their songs.

But what they have done is still better than many artists deliver, especially in the God-centered lyrics.


Lyrics: 4/5
Music: 3/5
Vocal(s): 5/5
Overall: 8/10

Friday

"Mirror" by BarlowGirl from Barlow Girl

"Who are you to tell me that I'm less than what I should be?" one Barlow sister demands of her mirror. "You don't define me!"

And so she has overcome the eating disorder that held her captive. The mirror's demands of perfection don't define her; God defines her, "and to Him [she has] beauty beyond compare." I know this song is powerful to those with experience to girls with eating disorders. It's not my favorite that I've heard from BarlowGirl, but that's likely due to its utter lack of applicability to me.

These girls certainly know how to use a piano. The cymbals sound a bit overused on the chorus of this song, but besides that it's another astounding Christian pop rock song of secular musical quality. I say that in a good way—secular songs sadly tend to be much higher quality than Christian ones, and I'm glad this is an exception.

The three Barlow sisters also know how to use their voices. They take advantage of their abilities, each one complimenting, accenting, and strengthening the others. Unlike some bands, they have something to show for the four years they've spent developing their skills.

Unfortunately, some parts of the song sound a bit less appealing than the others. Like "Never Alone, BarlowGirl provides this song as a sample on their PureVolume page.


Lyrics: 5/5
Music: 4/5
Vocal(s): 5/5
Overall: 8/10

Thursday

"Never Alone" by BarlowGirl from Barlow Girl

Wow! A contemporary Christian song of high quality! Since I first bothered to listen to BarlowGirl, I've kicked myself for avoiding this band for so long. (I'd feared they'd only gotten their popularity from the Superchick song that spoke of them.)

BarlowGirl is a better band than Superchick, whose overall nice music can have individual points that are annoying (though their lyrics are often excellent). The standard pop rock beat element isn't alone in the song "Never Alone"; at least one other well-written element underlines the main music.

Ooo, and does that piano make me wish I could play! It compliments the singing superbly. All three Barlow sisters play the instruments and sing. One sings the lead with her lovely voice, well-accented by her sisters. (I can't seem to find consistent reports of which one of them is the lead singer.) Their other album, Another Journal Entry, has an acoustic version of this song that evidently brings the piano bit to the forefront.

The slower tempo encourages a thoughtful consideration of the painful situation without spiking the listener's pulse through the roof. Though definitely a group catering to female Christian youth, it's still great lyrics for serious spiritual questions and practical spiritual application. More than their primary intended audience will enjoy them.

"Never Alone" flaunts the face of the touchy-feely songs so common in modern Christian music. "I cried out with no reply, and I can't feel You by my side, so I'll hold tight to what I know: You're here, and I'm never alone." This chorus may be a monster of a sentence, but it perfectly captures its image of loneliness. God's still there even when we don't feel Him.

This song breaks from the usual mould of Christian music being mediocre at best. The girls currently offer a sample listen to the regular version of the song on PureVolume.


Lyrics: 5/5
Music: 5/5
Vocal(s): 5/5
Overall: 10/10